Michaels NNN Investor Hub | Cap Rate Trends, Credit Rating Trends, Lease Terms & Due Diligence

Michaels loogo

Last Year Cap

8.0%

This Year Cap

8.2%

Cap Change

0.2%

Last Year Rating

B-

This Year Rating

B

Rating Change

No change

Michaels – NNN Cap Rate Trend

Cap Rate Trends

wdt_ID wdt_created_by wdt_created_at wdt_last_edited_by wdt_last_edited_at Tenant Year Cap Rate
5779 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,020 6.5
5780 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,021 6.3
5781 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,022 6.0
5782 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,023 6.3
5783 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,024 6.6
5784 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,025 6.6
Tenant Year Cap Rate

Credit (what net-lease buyers care about)

Credit Snapshot

Michaels

Cap Rates NNN
Last Year 8.0%
This Year 8.2%
Change 0.2%
S&P Rating CREDIT
Last Year B-
This Year B
Change Up

Michaels Net Lease: Secure, Essential Investment

Michaels is a well-known arts and crafts retailer with a nationwide footprint serving hobbyists, DIY enthusiasts, educators, and small businesses. This guide reviews cap rates, lease structures, tenant profile, and key due diligence considerations for buyers and sellers evaluating Michaels net lease investments.

For 1031 exchange buyers, Michaels properties can provide access to a recognizable retail brand with large-format stores, established trade areas, and long-term occupancy history. Investors should compare lease structure, rent growth, and location fundamentals when evaluating opportunities.

Investors often target Michaels assets for:

  • Established National Retail Brand
  • Large Format Retail Locations
  • Strong Consumer Demand in the Arts & Crafts Sector
  • Attractive 1031 Exchange Compatibility
  • Long-Term Occupancy History in Many Markets

Michaels Properties for 1031 Exchange Buyers

Michaels properties typically trade as net lease retail investments and may vary in lease structure, term remaining, rent escalations, renewal options, and landlord responsibilities. Buyers should carefully evaluate store performance, trade area demographics, lease economics, and real estate fundamentals to understand long-term risk and return potential.

Michaels – Credit Trend (S&P vs Moody’s)

Tenant_Rating_Trend

wdt_ID wdt_created_by wdt_created_at wdt_last_edited_by wdt_last_edited_at TenantKey Tenant Year Moody SP Moody_Grade SP_Grade Moody_GradeRank SP_GradeRank
1 admin2 2025 03:43 PM admin2 2025 03:43 PM 7eleveninc 7-Eleven, Inc. 2022 Baa2 A Lower Medium Grade Upper Medium Grade 5 6
2 admin2 2025 03:43 PM admin2 2025 03:43 PM 7eleveninc 7-Eleven, Inc. 2023 Baa2 A Lower Medium Grade Upper Medium Grade 5 6
3 admin2 2025 03:43 PM admin2 2025 03:43 PM 7eleveninc 7-Eleven, Inc. 2024 Baa2 A Lower Medium Grade Upper Medium Grade 5 6
4 admin2 2025 03:43 PM admin2 2025 03:43 PM 7eleveninc 7-Eleven, Inc. 2025 Baa2 A Lower Medium Grade Upper Medium Grade 5 6
5 admin2 2025 03:43 PM admin2 2025 03:43 PM 99centsonlystoresllc 99 Cents Only Stores, LLC 2022 Caa2 CCC+ Substantial Risk Substantial Risk 2 2
TenantKey Tenant Year Moody SP Moody_Grade SP_Grade Moody_GradeRank SP_GradeRank

Michaels Investment Market Statistics

AVERAGE SALE PRICE

$5,000,000

BUILDING SIZE

15,000 – 20,000 SF

AVERAGE NOI

$400,000

LAND

2.0 – 4.0 Acres

$/SF RANGE

$200 – $350

LEASE TERM SHOWN

15 years

Michaels Investor Snapshot (Quick Facts)

Origins & Growth (Past)

• Founded in 1973 in Texas
• Expanded nationwide through new store openings and acquisitions
• Became one of North America’s largest arts & crafts retailers
• Developed a strong presence in suburban retail corridors
• Expanded e-commerce and omnichannel capabilities
• Established a leading position in the arts, crafts, and DIY market

 

Where Michaels Stands Today

• Leading arts and crafts specialty retailer
• 1,300+ stores across North America
• Strong brand recognition among DIY and hobby consumers
• Primarily corporate-operated store base
• Expanding e-commerce and omnichannel capabilities
• Focus on merchandising, efficiency, and customer engagement
• Benefiting from continued demand for creative and seasonal products

Where Michaels Stands Today

  • Digital Expansion
  • Operational Efficiency
  • Omnichannel Growth
  • Customer Engagement
  • Portfolio Optimization
  • Product Innovation
  • Consumer Demand

 

 

Why investors buy Michaels NNN Properties or Michaels ground Lease Properties?

Pros (what buyers like)

  • Established National Retail Brand
    Michaels is one of North America’s largest arts and crafts retailers with a long operating history and strong brand recognition.
  • Resilient Hobby & DIY Demand
    Arts, crafts, seasonal décor, and DIY projects create a diversified customer base and recurring consumer demand.
  • Large Market Presence
    Michaels operates 1,300+ stores across North America, providing investors with a broad inventory of investment opportunities.
  • Attractive Real Estate Locations
    Many stores are located in established power centers, regional retail corridors, and high-traffic suburban markets.
  • 1031 Exchange Appeal
    Long-term NNN leases and passive ownership structures can be attractive to 1031 exchange and income-focused investors.

Cons (what can bite you)

  • Non-Investment-Grade Credit
    Unlike major banks or investment-grade retailers, Michaels carries higher perceived tenant credit risk.
  • Retail Industry Exposure
    Consumer spending trends, economic slowdowns, and changes in shopping behavior can impact retail performance.
  • Limited Rent Growth
    Many Michaels leases feature fixed rent schedules with modest or infrequent rent escalations.
  • Large Box Re-Tenanting Risk
    Store sizes are often 15,000–25,000 SF, which can require significant time and capital to re-lease if vacated.
  • E-Commerce Competition
    Although Michaels has expanded its online presence, competition from online retailers remains a long-term consideration.

Find out more

Michaels NNN properties, Michaels ground lease, Michaels net lease, Michaels cap rate, Michaels real estate, Michaels investment property, Michaels lease term, Michaels tenant profile, Michaels store count, Michaels NNN investment, Michaels 1031 exchange, arts and crafts retail investment, net lease retail property, Michaels commercial real estate, Michaels investment opportunities, single tenant Michaels, Michaels property for sale, retail NNN investments, Michaels lease structure, Michaels ground lease properties.

Michaels Background & History

Michaels is one of North America’s largest arts and crafts retailers, operating a nationwide network of stores that serve hobbyists, DIY enthusiasts, educators, makers, and seasonal shoppers. What began as a single arts and crafts store in Texas evolved into a leading specialty retail brand focused on creative products, home décor, framing, seasonal merchandise, and craft supplies.

Over time, the company expanded across the United States and Canada, building a strong presence in suburban retail corridors, power centers, and community shopping centers. Today, Michaels locations serve a broad customer base seeking products for crafting, decorating, gifting, education, and special events.

As consumer shopping habits have evolved, Michaels has adapted through e-commerce investments, omnichannel fulfillment options, loyalty programs, and digital engagement initiatives designed to complement its physical store network.

Why Michaels Matters to NNN Investors

Michaels operates more than 1,300 stores across North America and remains one of the most recognizable brands in the arts and crafts retail sector. The business model is supported by a diverse customer base and demand generated by DIY projects, seasonal events, home décor, celebrations, and educational activities.

Many Michaels stores are located in established retail corridors alongside national retailers, benefiting from strong traffic patterns, convenient access, and co-tenancy synergies. These locations often serve as destination shopping venues within their respective trade areas.

In addition, Michaels continues to enhance its omnichannel capabilities, customer loyalty programs, and merchandising strategies to strengthen customer engagement and operational performance.

This combination of brand recognition, broad consumer appeal, and established real estate locations helps explain why Michaels remains a popular tenant among net lease investors. Management continues to focus on operational efficiency, product innovation, and adapting to changing retail trends.

What Buyers and Sellers Should Evaluate

For investors evaluating Michaels NNN properties, a Michaels net lease, or a Michaels ground lease, the investment thesis is typically centered on real estate fundamentals, lease economics, tenant performance, and residual property value. As a result, buyers often place significant emphasis on location quality, lease structure, and replacement tenant potential.

Common searches include Michaels real estate, Michaels cap rate, Michaels lease term, Michaels tenant credit, and Michaels store performance. Ultimately, Michaels net lease value is driven by site-specific characteristics, lease economics, market demographics, and long-term real estate utility.

Because Michaels operates within the specialty retail sector, investors should carefully evaluate trade area strength, consumer spending trends, co-tenancy quality, and the property’s ability to attract future tenants if the store ever vacates.

In addition, buyers and sellers should assess long-term cash-flow durability, lease expiration risk, rent growth provisions, nearby competition, population trends, traffic counts, visibility, ingress and egress, and the overall strength of the surrounding retail corridor. Properties with strong demographics, established retail synergy, and functional large-format layouts generally command the greatest investor interest and pricing stability.

our team of experts are here for you

Our team helps investors evaluate NNN properties with practical, market-based guidance. In addition, we support buyers and sellers with lease review, pricing analysis, and due diligence strategy.

Whether you are comparing Michaels ground lease properties or fee simple Michaels assets, we can help you review the details that affect risk and long-term value. As a result, clients can make more confident decisions based on lease structure, location quality, and investment goals.

Scroll to Top