Casey’s General Stores NNN Investor Hub | Cap Rate Trends, Credit Rating Trends, Lease Terms & Due Diligence

Last Year Cap

6.4%

This Year Cap

6.6%

Cap Change

0.2%

Last Year Rating

BBB

This Year Rating

BBB

Rating Change

No change

Casey’s General Stores – NNN Cap Rate Trend

Cap Rate Trends

wdt_ID wdt_created_by wdt_created_at wdt_last_edited_by wdt_last_edited_at Tenant Year Cap Rate
5779 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,020 6.5
5780 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,021 6.3
5781 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,022 6.0
5782 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,023 6.3
5783 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,024 6.6
5784 admin2 2026 04:17 AM admin2 2026 04:17 AM 7 Brew 2,025 6.6
Tenant Year Cap Rate

Credit (what net-lease buyers care about)

Credit Snapshot

Casey’s General Stores

Cap Rates NNN
Last Year 6.4%
This Year 6.6%
Change 0.2%
S&P Rating CREDIT
Last Year BBB
This Year BBB
Change No change

Casey’s General Stores Net Lease: Secure, Essential Investment

Casey’s General Stores is a nationally recognized, investment-grade net lease tenant. This guide reviews cap rates, lease terms, tenant credit, and key due diligence considerations for buyers and sellers.

For 1031 exchange buyers, Casey’s General Stores Ground Lease Properties are important to compare against fee simple Casey’s assets, as lease structure can materially impact pricing, financing, and long-term resale value.

Investors often target Casey’s assets for:

  • Stable Income Potential
    Essential
  • Convenience Retail Demand
  • Strong Tenant Credit Profile
  • Attractive 1031 Exchange Compatibility

Casey’s General Stores Ground Lease Properties require close comparison of rent escalations, remaining lease term, extension options, and residual land value versus fee simple ownership.

Casey’s General Stores Ground Lease Properties for 1031 Exchange Buyers

Casey’s Ground Lease Properties often trade differently than fee simple Casey’s assets. Buyers should carefully evaluate lease structure, remaining term, renewal options, landlord responsibilities, and reversion rights to understand long-term risk and return.

Casey’s General Stores – Credit Trend (S&P vs Moody’s)

Tenant_Rating_Trend

wdt_ID wdt_created_by wdt_created_at wdt_last_edited_by wdt_last_edited_at TenantKey Tenant Year Moody SP Moody_Grade SP_Grade Moody_GradeRank SP_GradeRank
1 admin2 2025 03:43 PM admin2 2025 03:43 PM 7eleveninc 7-Eleven, Inc. 2022 Baa2 A Lower Medium Grade Upper Medium Grade 5 6
2 admin2 2025 03:43 PM admin2 2025 03:43 PM 7eleveninc 7-Eleven, Inc. 2023 Baa2 A Lower Medium Grade Upper Medium Grade 5 6
3 admin2 2025 03:43 PM admin2 2025 03:43 PM 7eleveninc 7-Eleven, Inc. 2024 Baa2 A Lower Medium Grade Upper Medium Grade 5 6
4 admin2 2025 03:43 PM admin2 2025 03:43 PM 7eleveninc 7-Eleven, Inc. 2025 Baa2 A Lower Medium Grade Upper Medium Grade 5 6
5 admin2 2025 03:43 PM admin2 2025 03:43 PM 99centsonlystoresllc 99 Cents Only Stores, LLC 2022 Caa2 CCC+ Substantial Risk Substantial Risk 2 2
TenantKey Tenant Year Moody SP Moody_Grade SP_Grade Moody_GradeRank SP_GradeRank

Casey's Stock Price (NASDAQ: CASY)

Casey’s General Stores Investment Market Statistics

AVERAGE SALE PRICE

$6,500,000

BUILDING SIZE

3,000 – 5,000 SF

AVERAGE NOI

$350,000

LAND

0.8 – 2.0 acres

$/SF RANGE

$250 – $450

LEASE TERM SHOWN

20 years

Casey’s General Stores Investor Snapshot (Quick Facts)

Origins & Growth (Past)

• Founded in 1968 in Iowa
• Expanded across Midwest markets
• Built strong rural store network
• Focused on convenience and fuel retail
• Introduced prepared food program (pizza)
• Grew into leading regional convenience chain

 

Where Casey’s General Stores Stands Today

• Strong Midwest-focused footprint
• Leader in convenience and fuel retail
• High daily customer traffic
• Corporate-operated store model
• Expanding prepared food and beverages
• Focus on efficiency and cost control

Where Casey’s General Stores Stands Today

• More digital ordering adoption
• Increased automation & efficiency
• Growth in mobile and loyalty platforms
• Stronger customer engagement
• Optimized store formats
• Focus on core food and fuel sales
• Benefiting from convenience retail demand

Why investors buy Casey’s General Stores NNN Properties or Casey’s General Stores ground Lease Properties?

Pros (what buyers like)

  • Strong tenant credit
    Investment-grade operator with consistent performance
  • Essential, daily-use retail
    Fuel and convenience items drive repeat, needs-based traffic
  • Defensive rural and suburban footprint
    Less direct competition vs. urban retail corridors
  • Attractive lease structures
    Long-term NNN or ground leases appeal to passive and 1031 buyers

Cons (what can bite you)

  • Lease structure variability
    Some assets may be NN or modified NNN with landlord responsibilities
  • Limited rent growth
    Many leases include modest or infrequent rent escalations
  • Location concentration risk
    Heavy Midwest exposure may limit geographic diversification
  • Re-tenanting considerations
    Smaller-market locations can reduce replacement tenant pool

Find out more

Casey’s General Stores Background & History

Casey’s General Stores is a national convenience retail company best known for its network of neighborhood stores offering fuel, food, and everyday essentials. What began as a small Midwestern convenience store evolved into a leading operator focused on daily-use retail and prepared food offerings.

Over time, the company built a strong regional footprint, particularly across the Midwest, expanding through organic growth and acquisitions. Today, customers rely on Casey’s locations for fuel, groceries, and its well-known prepared food program, especially pizza.

As consumer preferences have shifted toward convenience and speed, the company has adapted through digital ordering, loyalty programs, and operational efficiencies that support high transaction volumes.

Why Casey’s General Stores Matters to NNN Investors

Casey’s operates a large network of convenience stores, serving consistent demand driven by fuel sales and daily-use purchases. The business model is centered on repeat visits, essential retail demand, and locations positioned along commuter routes and in underserved rural and suburban markets.

Many stores are located on well-positioned sites with strong accessibility, helping support steady traffic. In addition, the company’s prepared food offerings provide higher-margin revenue streams that enhance unit-level performance.

This combination of fuel, convenience retail, and food service helps explain why Casey’s remains resilient within the evolving retail landscape. Management continues to invest in technology, store upgrades, and operational improvements to support long-term growth.

What Buyers and Sellers Should Evaluate

For investors evaluating Casey’s General Stores NNN properties, a Casey’s net lease, or a Casey’s ground lease, the investment thesis is typically centered on real estate fundamentals and tenant credit strength.

Common searches include Casey’s real estate, Casey’s cap rate, Casey’s lease term, Casey’s tenant credit, and store performance. Ultimately, Casey’s net lease value is driven by site-specific factors, lease economics, and how the location fits within the company’s broader network.

As convenience retail trends continue to evolve, the strongest Casey’s locations tend to be those that remain essential within their trade areas. Buyers and sellers should evaluate each property individually, including visibility, traffic counts, access, surrounding population, competition, and lease language defining landlord responsibilities.

In addition, investors should consider long-term cash-flow durability, fuel performance (if applicable), and how the asset may perform across different hold periods and exit strategies.

our team of experts are here for you

Our team helps investors evaluate NNN properties with practical, market-based guidance. In addition, we support buyers and sellers with lease review, pricing analysis, and due diligence strategy.

Whether you are comparing Casey’s General Stores ground lease properties or fee simple Casey’s General Stores assets, we can help you review the details that affect risk and long-term value. As a result, clients can make more confident decisions based on lease structure, location quality, and investment goals.

Scroll to Top